When David Lee Roth left Van Halen in 1985, the band had big shoes to fill. Montrose vocalist Sammy Hagar ultimately got the job, leading the group to its first Number 1 album with 1986’s 5150. But he wasn’t the only candidate. Scandal frontwoman Patty Smyth was also considered for the role, former bass guitarist Michael Anthony has confirmed, shedding new light on one of rock’s most intriguing what-ifs.
Roth’s departure followed a period of growing tension within the band. One oft-repeated account suggests that Eddie Van Halen’s guest solo on Michael Jackson’s “Beat It” contributed to the singer’s decision to leave, as Eddie’s celebrity status continued to grow. Roth subsequently launched a solo career, recruiting Steve Vai in what was widely seen as an attempt to match his former bandmate’s guitar firepower.
Speaking at the Rock and Roll Fantasy Camp earlier this month, Anthony addressed the long-standing rumor that Smyth was among the candidates to replace Roth, admitting that it’s “a grey area.”
“Patty Smyth actually was considered at one point,” he confirms (via Blabbermouth). “And this was Eddie. When Dave left, it kind of threw us all in a bit of a tailspin. Warner Brothers wanted us to change the name of the band right away, hoping that one day Dave would come back, and we could resume the Van Halen thing.”
Anthony appeared on every Van Halen studio album through 1998’s Van Halen III, although his bass playing was limited to just three tracks on that record. He was subsequently replaced in the lineup by Eddie’s son, Wolfgang, who played on 2012’s A Different Kind of Truth. Anthony was a core member of the group, and he says there were serious concerns about its future following Roth’s departure.
“It was kind of like the fairy tale was over, and Ed was kind of freaking out a bit,” he recalls.
Still, the band vowed to move forward and began looking for a new singer.
“There were quite a few people that either jammed with us or Ed had spoken to, so we really didn’t know,” Anthony continues. “We all kind of decided [that] we didn’t need Patty Smyth to come in. Having a girl come in singing songs about girls wasn’t gonna fit.”
Smyth was enjoying considerable success at the time as the frontwoman of Scandal, who had scored hits with “Goodbye to You” and “Love’s Got a Line on You” before breaking through with “The Warrior.” The band’s 1984 sophomore album, Warrior, became a hit in its own right, spending 41 weeks on the Billboard 200 and peaking at number 17. The singer was also close to the Van Halen camp through her friendship with Eddie’s then-wife, Valerie Bertinelli.

“They came on tour with us, Valerie and Ed,” she once told LifeMinute’s Joann Butler. “He was starting to talk about it then.”
Eddie and Valerie spent time on the road with Scandal during the Warrior touring cycle, and Eddie even made occasional guest appearances onstage with the group. Given his enthusiasm for Smyth’s voice, she seemed a natural candidate to take over from Roth.
However, she has offered a different explanation for why the proposed partnership never came to fruition. At the time, Smyth was pregnant with her daughter Ruby, whose father is her first husband, punk singer and bassist Richard Hell. She has been married to tennis champion John McEnroe since 1997.
“When I was eight months pregnant, he said ‘You’ve gotta let me know now,’” she recalled. “And I just was like, ‘No, I can’t do it. I’m really pregnant. I don’t want to move to L.A.’
In retrospect, I really wish that we had made a record together.”
— Patty Smyth
“I think if he had said to me, ‘Let’s make a record,’ then that would have been different. But I mean, it’s terrible to say this, but I loved him. I don’t know if I loved the music that much, but I think it was timing. Timing’s everything.
“In retrospect, I really wish that we had made a record together. That would have been great.”
There was another reason the story remained under wraps for so long. Smyth later revealed that Eddie had specifically asked her not to discuss his invitation publicly because he didn’t want Hagar to appear to have been second choice.
Hagar, who fronted Van Halen for four studio albums, has since said he made Eddie a better musician during their time together — a claim that contrasts with Alex Van Halen’s assessment of Hagar’s tenure.
Meanwhile, the drummer has claimed that Anthony was offered the chance to play on Van Halen’s final studio album, while Steve Vai has revealed that Eddie called him on the day he left Roth’s band, setting the stage for a friendship between the two guitarists.


